Repair or Replace Your Deck?
What cracked, split boards say about an older deck, why the frame under them settles the question, and what a replacement costs around Santa Maria.

Quick Answer
Checked and split boards don't mean a whole new deck on their own, because boards can be swapped out while the frame under them stays. The footings, posts, beams and joists are what decide it: in good shape, a repair or new boards and railing on them costs less than a new deck. Where they need work in a lot of places, starting over around Santa Maria, on a typical deck of roughly 16 by 20 feet, runs $12,000 to $28,000 in pressure-treated wood or $17,000 to $36,000 in composite.
A Repair, New Boards or a New Deck
A repair. If the problems are in a few spots, such as a split board, a loose section of railing, a tired step or a post, those get fixed and everything else stays as it is.
New boards over the same frame. When the boards are worn all over but what holds them up is sound, new boards and railing go onto that frame. You keep everything under the boards, which is why it costs less than a whole new deck.
A new deck. When the frame needs work in a lot of places, or you'd like a deck of a different size or shape, the old deck comes down and a new one goes up in its place. That's a deck replacement.
What Checked and Split Boards Mean
Checks are cracks that open along the grain on the face of a board, and a split is a crack that goes right through it. Checking and splitting are the most common reason a wood deck gets torn out and replaced, more than rot. They're in the boards you walk on, though, not in the frame that holds them up.
What you might see on the boards
- Silvery gray wood: weathered wood on the coast often turns that color, and a board can be gray and still whole
- Black spots: often mildew, which stains wood but doesn't rot it, and it gets cleaned off before a new coat of stain
- Cracks along the grain on the face: checking
- A crack running through a board: a split, and a board we'd replace
- A board that feels soft or gives underfoot: a reason to look at what's under it
If the boards are whole and it's only the color that's gone, cleaning the deck and giving it new penetrating stain can be all it needs.
What We Look at Under the Boards
The footings, posts, beams and joists carry everything you see on top, so they're what we look at first. If rot turns up once old boards come up, it's priced as extra, on top of the repair.
If a repair will do, we'll tell you.

What a Deck Replacement Costs Around Santa Maria
The table prices a typical deck here, roughly 16 by 20 feet, with three steps to the lawn and railing along its open sides, when the old deck is removed and a new one built in its place. Taking the old deck off is part of both figures.
| Typical deck, old one removed and new one built | Around Santa Maria |
|---|---|
| Pressure-treated wood | $12,000 to $28,000 |
| Composite | $17,000 to $36,000 |
If it's a repair instead. Around Santa Maria, deck repair cost typically runs $600 to $2,000 for a few boards, a post or a loose section of railing, and $2,000 to $6,000 for bigger work, such as rot in the frame, a run of railing or the stairs.
More on this: Deck Replacement in Santa Maria
When You Want to Redo a Deck for Less
What is the cheapest way to redo a deck?
Keep the frame, if it's sound. When the frame under the boards is still in good shape, a repair to the worn spots, cleaning and staining boards that are still whole, or new boards and railing on that frame all cost less than starting over. Around Santa Maria, a small repair, such as a few boards, a post or a loose section of railing, typically runs $600 to $2,000. Starting over on a deck around 16 by 20 feet costs $12,000 to $28,000 with pressure-treated wood and $17,000 to $36,000 with composite.
